top of page
  • garytbyrne2

Unlocking Your Basement's Potential: Finishing your Basement vs. Adding a Secondary Suite

Your basement holds untapped potential, ready to transform into valuable living space. But before diving in, it's crucial to understand the key differences between finishing your basement and adding a secondary suite. Both options offer unique benefits, but the choice ultimately depends on your goals and needs.

The Difference Between:

When you choose to finish your basement, you're essentially converting it into usable living space without the intention of creating a separate dwelling unit. This can involve adding insulation, drywall, flooring, lighting, and other amenities to create additional rooms such as a family room, home office, or entertainment area.

On the other hand, adding a secondary suite involves creating a self-contained living space within your basement, complete with its own kitchen, bathroom, and living area. This option provides the opportunity for rental income or housing extended family members while maintaining privacy and independence.

Building and Fire Codes Differences:

Finishing Your Basement:

  1. Insulation:

  • The perimeter of the foundation wall must be fully insulated using an insulating material with a minimum effective thermal resistance required by the NBC(AE).

  • Foamed plastic insulation materials must be protected by a thermal barrier, such as gypsum board, to prevent the release of toxic gases in case of fire.

  1. Vapour Barrier:

  • Must be installed on the warm side of the insulation to prevent moisture buildup within the walls.

  1. Egress from Bedrooms:

  • Each bedroom must have at least one window that can be opened from the inside without the use of tools or special knowledge.

  • The window must provide an unobstructed opening with a minimum area of 0.35 m2 (3.77 square feet) and no dimension less than 380 mm (15 inches).

  • If a window opens into a window-well, a clearance of at least 760 mm (30 inches) between the window and the wall of the window-well is required.

  1. Smoke Alarms:

  • Smoke alarms must conform to the CAN/ULC-S531 “Smoke Alarms” standard.

  • At least one smoke alarm must be installed on each storey, including basements, in each sleeping room and in a location between the sleeping room(s) and the remainder of the storey.

  • Smoke alarms must be hard-wired to an electrical circuit and interconnected so that when one alarm sounds, all alarms within the dwelling unit will sound.

  1. Carbon Monoxide Alarms:

  • Carbon monoxide alarms must be installed inside each bedroom or outside each bedroom within 5 m of each bedroom door.

  • It is highly recommended to install carbon monoxide alarms in all homes, even those that predate the requirements.

  • Carbon monoxide alarms must conform to CAN/CSA-6.19 “Residential Carbon Monoxide Alarming Devices” standard.

Adding a Secondary Suite:

1. Ceiling Height Requirement:

  • The minimum ceiling height for living spaces in a secondary suite is 1.95 m (78”), in line with common practice for unfinished basements. Existing secondary suites may have a lower minimum height, subject to evaluation by a safety codes officer.

2. Smoke-Tight Barriers:

  • Ensure smoke-tight barriers by using 1⁄2-inch drywall for walls, ceiling, and exits. This prevents the spread of fire between units and provides crucial time for evacuation.

3. Outdoor Exit Requirement:

  • All secondary suites must have a direct exit to the outdoors to facilitate evacuation in case of fire or emergency. If exits lead through a main floor vestibule, adequate protection with 12.7 mm (1⁄2-inch) gypsum board is necessary.

4. Bedroom Window Requirements:

  • Every bedroom in a secondary suite must have at least one window for emergency escape during a fire. These windows must have a minimum area of 0.35 m2 (3.77 square feet) and no dimension less than 380 mm (15 inches), and be operable without tools or technical knowledge.

5. Smoke and Carbon Monoxide Alarm Installation:

  • Homes with secondary suites must have interconnected smoke alarms and carbon monoxide alarms installed in both dwellings. Smoke alarms must be present in each bedroom and hallway, conforming to CAN/ULC-S531 standard.

6. Enclosure of Gas-Fired Appliances:

  • Gas-fired furnaces and water heaters in secondary suites must be enclosed in rooms with fire-protected walls and ceilings using 1⁄2-inch drywall to prevent fire hazards and carbon monoxide poisoning.

7. Independent Heating and Ventilation:

  • Secondary suites must have independent heating and ventilation systems to prevent rapid smoke migration between units, as demonstrated by previous fire studies

Price per Square Foot Difference: 

The cost difference between finishing your basement and adding a secondary suite can vary significantly. Finishing your basement tends to be more cost-effective, as it primarily involves renovating existing space. However, adding a secondary suite involves additional expenses such as installing a kitchen, bathroom fixtures, and meeting regulatory requirements, which can increase the overall cost per square foot.


Whether you're considering finishing your basement or adding a secondary suite, it's essential to weigh the benefits, costs, and regulatory requirements carefully. Finishing your basement offers the flexibility to create additional living space tailored to your needs, while adding a secondary suite opens up possibilities for rental income or accommodating extended family members.

Whichever option you choose, ensuring compliance with building and fire codes is paramount to the safety and functionality of your space. By understanding the differences outlined above and consulting with professionals when needed, you can embark on your basement renovation journey with confidence, knowing that you're making informed decisions to maximize the potential of your home.

For more information reach out to us at

39 views0 comments


Calgary General Contractors


bottom of page